SAN ANTONIO – A jury will have to decide this week whether the fatal stabbing of a John Jay High School student during a lunch break last year was an act of murder or self-defense.
Jesus San Miguel is accused of killing Joshua Kinnaman, 18, on April 4, 2023.
The incident occurred at La Fiesta de Jalisco, a restaurant across the street from the school, where the two had gone during their break.
Prosecutors allege Kinnaman was upset with something San Miguel said to his girlfriend, prompting Kinnaman to challenge him to a fight.
According to the state’s opening argument, Kinnaman initiated the altercation by pushing San Miguel and throwing a punch. San Miguel then reportedly drew a knife and fatally stabbed his friend.
He then ran from the scene and never called 911.
“You can’t bring a knife to a fist fight, that is what this case is all about,” prosecutor Raul Jordan said.
The defense, however, painted a different picture, arguing that San Miguel was trying to de-escalate the situation.
“He doesn’t rush at him and stab him. He doesn’t stab him multiple times,” defense attorney Charles Bunk told the court. “Jesus has the knife; he [Kinnaman] runs into the knife, basically.”
Several classmates who were present during the altercation testified that they were unaware of any animosity between the two young men. Both were described as friends and not typically known for violence.
As testimony continues, the jury will ultimately have to decide if San Miguel acted in self-defense or if he is guilty of murder.
If convicted, San Miguel faces the possibility of life in prison.
Related Stories: